Did you know that ecommerce businesses worldwide lose billions of dollars annually due to chargebacks? That highlights the importance of being well-informed as chargebacks are a significant challenge that both merchants and consumers need to understand.

A chargeback is essentially a forced transaction reversal initiated by the issuing bank at the request of the cardholder. Unlike a refund, which is directly processed by the merchant, chargebacks involve the bank stepping in to make sure consumers are protected.  Understanding the ins and outs of chargebacks is important for both merchants, who face financial and reputational risks, and consumers, who rely on chargebacks as a safeguard against fraud and unsatisfactory purchases.

What is a Chargeback?

A chargeback is a return of funds to a consumer, initiated by the issuing bank. It occurs when a consumer disputes a credit or debit card transaction, claiming that it was unauthorized or that the product or service was not delivered as promised. The bank then investigates the claim, and if it is found to be valid, the funds are taken back from the merchant and returned to the consumer.

How are Chargebacks Different than Refunds?

Refunds are voluntarily processed by businesses in response to customer dissatisfaction, while chargebacks are initiated by the issuing bank. This adds an additional layer of complexity and potential conflict, as the merchant or business owner may not know about the payment dispute until after the chargeback has been processed.

Regulations and card network rules lead the chargeback process to ensure fairness and consistency. These rules vary by credit card network (such as Visa, Mastercard, and American Express) and are designed to protect consumers while providing a clear process for businesses to follow in resolving disputes.

Common Reasons for Chargebacks

  • Fraudulent Transactions: Unauthorized credit card transactions.
  • Product/Service Issues: Discrepancies between what was advertised and what was delivered.
  • Technical Problems: Errors such as duplicate transactions or incorrect amounts.
  • Customer Disputes: Misunderstandings or dissatisfaction with the purchase.

The Chargeback Process

Initiation

The chargeback process begins when a cardholder notices a transaction they want to dispute. This could be due to unauthorized transactions, non-delivery of goods or services, or dissatisfaction with a product. The cardholder then contacts their issuing bank to initiate the chargeback. The issuing bank will ask the cardholder to provide details about the transaction and the reason for the dispute.

Investigation

Once the chargeback is initiated, the issuing bank begins an investigation. This involves several steps:

  • Requesting Information: The issuing bank will request documentation from the cardholder to support their claim. This could include transaction receipts, correspondence with the merchant, or any other relevant information.
  • Temporary Reversal: In many cases, the issuing bank will temporarily reverse the transaction, removing the funds from the businesses’ account and crediting them back to the cardholder. This is done to protect the cardholder’s interests while the investigation is ongoing.
  • Merchant Notification: The merchant is notified of the chargeback and given an opportunity to respond. This notification typically includes details about the transaction and the reason for the chargeback.

Resolution

The resolution stage involves the merchant’s response and the final decision by the issuing bank. Here are the key steps:

  • Merchant Response: The merchant has a specified period (usually 7-14 days, depending on the card network) to respond to the chargeback. The response should include all relevant documentation to refute the chargeback, such as proof of delivery, transaction records, and communication with the cardholder.
  • Bank Review: The issuing bank reviews the merchant’s response along with the cardholder’s original claim. This review is thorough and aims to determine whether the chargeback is valid.
  • Decision: Based on the evidence, the issuing bank makes a final decision. There are three possible outcomes:
  1. Approval: If the bank finds in favor of the cardholder, the chargeback is upheld, and the temporary reversal becomes permanent.
  2. Rejection: If the bank finds in favor of the merchant, the chargeback is reversed, and the funds are returned to the merchant.
  3. Arbitration: In some cases, if the decision is not clear-cut or if either party disagrees with the decision, the case may go to arbitration. This involves further review and a final binding decision by the card network.

Post-Resolution

After the final decision, both parties must comply with the outcome.

For merchants, this could mean accepting the loss if the chargeback is approved or reclaiming the funds if the chargeback is rejected. Merchants may also face additional fees and penalties, such as a chargeback fee or increased scrutiny from payment processors, especially if they have a high chargeback ratio.

For cardholders, a successful chargeback means the disputed amount is permanently credited back to their account. If the chargeback is rejected, they may need to explore other dispute resolution methods or accept the purchase as legitimate.

The Impact of Chargebacks on Businesses

Chargebacks can have significant negative impacts on businesses, not only from a financial and operational aspect, but can also damage their reputation.

Financial Costs & Losses

  • Chargeback Fees: Each chargeback incurs chargeback fees from the payment processor, which can range from $20 to $100 per incident, depending on the processor and the nature of the transaction.
  • Lost Revenue: When a chargeback is approved, the merchant loses the sale amount, which can be especially damaging if the transaction involved high-ticket items.
  • Shipping and Handling Costs: Merchants often lose the costs associated with shipping and handling, even if the product is not returned.
  • Additional Penalties: High chargeback ratios can lead to higher fees, reserve requirements, or even termination of the merchant account.
  • Increased Processing Fees: Businesses with high chargeback rates may face increased credit card processing fees as they are considered higher risk by payment processors.
  • Revenue Loss from Preventive Measures: Implementing fraud prevention measures (like advanced verification systems) can result in additional operational costs and potentially lost sales if legitimate transactions are mistakenly flagged as fraudulent.

Operational Burden

  • Time-Consuming Dispute Management: Handling a chargeback involves significant time and resources, including gathering documentation, responding to disputes, and communicating with banks and customers.
  • Training Staff: Employees need to be trained on chargeback procedures, which adds to operational costs and diverts focus from other business activities.
  • Customer Service: Increased chargeback disputes often mean higher demands on customer service teams, which need to handle inquiries and complaints, potentially leading to longer response times and decreased customer satisfaction.
  • System Integration: Implementing and maintaining systems to track and manage chargebacks requires technical resources and ongoing support.

Reputation Damage

  • Processor Relationships: A high chargeback ratio can damage a business’s relationship with payment processors. This can lead to merchant account closures, which disrupt the ability to accept credit cards and affect cash flow.
  • Brand Perception: Repeated chargebacks can harm a business’s reputation, leading customers to perceive the brand as unreliable or untrustworthy. Negative reviews and word-of-mouth can worsen this perception.
  • Loyalty and Retention: Customers who experience issues that lead to chargebacks are less likely to return, affecting customer retention and lifetime value.

12 Ways to Prevent Chargebacks

Here are 12 best practices merchants can put in place to help reduce chargebacks:

  • 1. Return and Refund Policies: Clearly state and display your return and refund policies on your website and during checkout.
  • 2. Customer Support: Provide accessible and responsive customer support through multiple channels like phone, email, and live chat.
  • 3. Order Confirmation: Send immediate order confirmation emails and regular updates about order status, including shipping and delivery information.
  • 4. Accurate Descriptions: Provide detailed and accurate product descriptions with high-quality images.
  • 5. Billing Descriptors: Ensure the billing descriptor on credit card statements is recognizable and consistent with your brand.
  • 6. Comprehensive Order Info: Include detailed transaction information in confirmation emails, such as product names, prices, taxes, and delivery dates.
  • 7. Fraud Detection Tools: Implement fraud detection systems to identify and prevent suspicious transactions.
  • 8. Authentication Methods: Use multi-factor authentication.
  • 9. Update Security Protocols: Regularly update your payment systems and security measures to protect against fraud.
  • 10. Proactive Service: Encourage customers to contact your support team with any issues or concerns about their orders.
  • 11. Educational Content: Provide information on your website and in emails about your policies and how to recognize legitimate charges.
  • 12. Follow-Up Emails: Send follow-up emails to confirm satisfaction and ask for feedback to resolve issues before they escalate.

By following these best practices and focusing on clear communication and customer education, businesses can reduce the likelihood of chargebacks, provide a positive shopping experience and build customer trust.

Handling Chargebacks Effectively

Effectively handling chargebacks is imperative for reducing their financial and operational impact on a business. This involves maintaining detailed documentation, following a structured dispute resolution process, and working closely with payment processors.

Importance of Documentation:

Maintaining detailed records of all credit card transactions is the foundation of handling chargebacks effectively. Comprehensive documentation provides the evidence needed to dispute invalid chargebacks. Key records to maintain include:

  • Transaction Details:
    Keep detailed records of every transaction, including dates, amounts, and payment methods. Ensure that these records include itemized receipts, order confirmations, shipping details, and tracking numbers.
  • Communication Logs:
    Document all communication with customers, including emails, phone calls, and chat transcripts. This can help show your efforts to resolve any issues before they escalate to a chargeback.
  • Proof of Delivery:
    For physical goods, retain proof of delivery, such as tracking numbers, delivery confirmation, and signed delivery receipts. For digital goods, keep records of download or access logs.
  • Return and Refund Documentation:
    Maintain records of return requests, refund approvals, and processed refunds. This helps show that you have a transparent and efficient return policy.
  • Having this documentation readily available not only helps in disputing chargebacks but also demonstrates to payment processors and banks that your business operates transparently and professionally.

Dispute Resolution: Responding to Chargebacks

When a chargeback occurs, responding promptly and systematically is key. Here are the steps to follow in the dispute resolution process:

  • Review the Chargeback Notice:
    As soon as you receive a chargeback notification, review the details carefully. Understand the reason for the chargeback and gather relevant transaction documentation.
  • Prepare Your Response:
    Compile all necessary evidence to support your case. This includes transaction records, communication logs, proof of delivery, and any other relevant documents.
  • Submit Your Response:
    Respond to the chargeback within the specified timeframe, usually 7-14 days. Submit your evidence through the payment processor’s dispute resolution platform or as directed by the issuing bank.
  • Follow-Up:
    Monitor the status of your chargeback dispute. If additional information is requested, provide it promptly. Stay in communication with your payment processor to ensure the process is progressing.
  • Learn from Each Case:
    After the dispute is resolved, analyze the outcome to identify any patterns or areas for improvement. Use this information to refine your processes and prevent future chargebacks.

Collaborate with Your Payment Processor

Building a strong relationship with your payment processor is essential for effective chargeback management. Payment processors can provide valuable support and guidance throughout the chargeback process:

  • Utilize Resources and Tools:
    Many payment processors offer tools and resources to help manage and prevent chargebacks, such as fraud detection systems, chargeback alerts, and dispute management platforms. Take advantage of these resources to streamline your processes.
  • Seek Expert Advice:
    Payment processors have expertise in handling chargebacks and can offer advice on best practices for preventing and disputing them.
  • Stay Informed:
    Payment processors often update their policies and procedures based on changes in industry regulations and credit card company rules. Stay informed about these updates to ensure your business remains compliant and prepared.
  • Collaborate on Prevention Strategies:
    Work with your payment processor to develop and implement strategies for preventing chargebacks. This might include improving fraud detection, enhancing customer communication, and refining your return policies. 

Wrapping Up

Understanding and effectively managing chargebacks is critical for all businesses. By staying informed about the chargeback process, implementing best practices to prevent disputes, maintaining detailed transaction records, and collaborating closely with payment processors, businesses can minimize the financial and reputational impacts of chargebacks.

Ready to see how Clearent by Xplor can help guide you through the chargeback process?

Let’s Chat!

Article by Clearent by Xplor

First published: July 24 2024

Last updated: September 27 2024